Performance appraisals are a necessary procedure undertaken by a Project Manager to give feedback to team members on their everyday work performance. This task generally has negative undertones but in reality this can be a great way to help improve performance of team members and help build cohesion on the team.
Here are a few tips to keep in mind for performance appraisals:
- Don’t treat all employees the same. It is a good idea to have quarterly interim appraisals to give the marginal employees more feedback on what they need to do to improve performance. Outstanding employees may only need a mid-year assessment. Appraisals are and need to be an effective tool for building high performance employees.
- Never delay or cancel appraisal meetings. Postponing appraisals is disrespectful and leaved too much room for doubt in the mind of the employee being appraised. If Project Managers are not able to commit to the review process and do it on a regular basis then they shouldn’t be a Project Manager.
- Never forget that the appraisal process is for performance improvement, not salary administration. Appraisals are a key component of salary administration, but if an employee is at the maximum salary for their pay band you should not stop conducting performance appraisals for that employee.
- The purpose of an appraisal is to provide an accurate assessment of performance, not to place blame. By assessing performance accurately the manager and employee can work in an environment of trust and confidence. This is critical to team building and trying to make the team member a better more efficient employee.
- During the appraisal goals should be created and progress toward those goals should be charted. When goals are achieved take time to formally acknowledge that. When goals are not met do the same and work with the employee to figure out how to achieve the goal and get back on track to top performance.

